Right at the beginning of this quarter, we read a piece called Guests and Aliens by Saskia Sassen which describes patterns in global human migration from a sociological perspective. In the excerpt we read, Sassen mentions that contrary to popular belief, those who immigrate usually aren't overjoyed to do so. In fact, people would not choose to leave their country of origin if they did not happen. Sassen cites migration data from the European Union to back up these statements, saying "only 5 million EU nationals out of a total population of well over 350 million reside in an EU country which is not their country of origin", despite the freedom to do so and the differences in quality of life and economic opportunities between countries. In light of this observation, it seems as if people who are reluctant to leave their home countries but do, based on complex and push and pull factors, might try and insulate themselves in some way from the culture they are joining. At the same time, a complex cultural dynamic between the new culture and the old culture emerges, and I am interested in characterizing and exploring this dynamic as it relates to the Turkish-German immigration issues we're focusing on in this program. Ideally, I will use semi-structured interviews to construct an ethnography of this culture. I want to figure out which elements of the culture people emigrate from become thematized and prioritized when forming a new Turkish cultural identity within the new German culture. I also would like to find out what elements of German culture immigrants choose to adopt into their own individual identity.
Not only would I like to interview our guest speakers and perhaps people I meet over the duration of the trip, but I would also like to interview our group of students. I'm curious to see what elements of "American-ness" we're eager to shed in favor of blending in with German culture and which elements we choose to assert even more. I would like to ask people about things they miss, behaviors they find difficult to curb, and other relevant questions, if of course they agree :)
Monday, June 13, 2011
Thursday, April 7, 2011
Sassen Reflection
In the first few pages of the reading, Sassen draws attention to the fact that people tend not to migrate from poorer to richer regions, even during periods when border supervision and immigration legislation were less strict. This observation really struck me as interesting, because it seems to be counterintuitive to many of the things one hears about immigration and migration, especially in the United States. I was also surprised to hear that few people living in the EU move to other EU countries with better job opportunities or better socioeconomic conditions when they are quite free to do so. To me, this highlights a concept that I think will be key when discussing "mobilizations of identity" this quarter and throughout the summer. That concept is that people, on the whole, are reluctant to leave their communities of origin unless some strong push and pull forces motivate them to do so. Remembering this concept will certainly be helpful when we begin talking about the strategies people use to acclimate to a new cultural climate and adapt or do not adapt to a new home. I can definitely see why people would want to group themselves in a particular district of a new city and seek out those who have migrated from the same country, especially keeping in mind that many people are conflicted about leaving home. I can also see why purposeful, explicit cultural expression might become integral in a person's life when before it was just second nature. Unfortunately, as Sassen also brings up, this expression of culture might provoke a racialization response from the residents of the country to which these individuals migrated. Sassen posits that this racialization is more due to the "outsiderness" of the new group or individual than the actual cultural practices themselves. However, this racialization and suspicion of outsiders likely provokes an increased need for immigrants to insulate themselves from the new culture and thus a cycle may persist. I look forward to learning more about how this dynamic might exist in the Turkish culture in Berlin, perhaps how Berliners overcome the urge to judge or racialize, and even how Turkish immigrants blend their culture with that of Berlin and reinvent their identity.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)